The info re: the father's death was reported as information from a book, You do not have permission to delete messages in this group, NOTE: Minor details from Firestarter & Green Mile later in this post -. Earlier in the book, she takes only five Points from Hermione for her allegedly going to fight a mountain troll on her own. Given that Lupin had a transformation after Hallowe'en but before the following weekend, the full moon would have had to be sometime in the first week of November. Therefore, Yaxley should not have been able to learn the secret simply by grabbing onto Hermione and not letting go, as this would not have been voluntary on Hermione's part. It is also possible that there are more dormitories that don't appear in the books and films. As she is a year older than him it should have been "in your third year.". This may have been a covert way of implying this, especially considering Riddle may have missed this action by Dumbledore. Viewers would think that the show's narrative would bounce between the adventures on Fraser's Ridge and Young Ian's experiences with the Mohawk, but the young character has not had any screen time since the season four finale. However, it's possible that Fudge wanted to charge Harry with this anyway as part of his. On page 342 of the American version, there is a punctuation error when. It can also be little things. Following that logic, Katie should have been picked instead of Harry, but she did not even consider herself becoming Captain when she says, " "I thought you'd get that, well done," she called over, pointing at the Captain's badge on Harry's chest. For such a long buildup, the aftermath of Culloden was practically dropped from the narrative. When Jamie first left William at Helwater, The boy had dark brown, near black hair that reflected his mother's; however, when he resurfaces in season five, the character has red hair that mirrors Jamie. It is also possible that this Prime Minister is fictional and not intended to be any real-life figure. Although with The Burrow being such a haphazard building, it is likely that it contains more than just one attic (an attic referring to a room beneath the eaves). Written before and immediately after the birth of her first child, these poems try to imagine the future her son will inherit. _That_ alwaysbugged me! This was fixed in later editions of the book. Other teachers, such as McGonagall or Flitwick, may know how to properly install a new headmaster, but they willingly withheld this information from Umbridge. There is one moment in a story that is the most at risk for this brand of error and that is the climax. Why didn't Harry or Hermione or Ron think of using a summoning charm for anything they wanted to eat? You can visit the. The Bloomsbury Original Adult Edition cover depicts the Hogwarts Express as a Norfolk & Western J class (specifically #602), a class of streamlined steam locomotives that was used in the United States and would be too large for the British loading gauge. However, this could just be Harry and Hermione's speculation based on their limited knowledge on the Fidelius Charm. Even though some storylines need to be omitted for the sake of an overarching television narrative, coverage of Marsali's childhood was greatly missed. It is possible the Boggart took the form of Moody's greatest fear and thus he was able to recognise it as a Boggart, but it has never been established that Boggarts can take on a subjective form if observed indirectly. However, this might be related to the current school year, for which her record was actually clean. When Ron is explaining to Harry his plan to use the ghoul as a decoy Ron "with spattergroit", Rowling writes 'Harry merely looked his confusion'. Continuity errors that result from the editing process are among the details that fans of the film series enjoy looking for. Prefects have authority over the students, but they are equal to each other. Free Shipping & Price Match Guarantee This could not be, as Ron should still be on the bed. Remember: nothing ever stops existing even if its not currently mentioned on the page. Places are usually synonymous for location based continuity errors, but can also mean the details of said location or place. If nobody could acquire the Stone if they wanted to use it, then it is unclear how Nicolas Flamel was supposed to get it in order to make more. Request a Price Match, Must be purchased in multiples of 25 copies, Pre-order this book today and they will ship when released on May 23rd 2023, Below are the available bulk discount rates for each individual item when you purchase a certain amount. He goes to bed.We>then read all about the way Vicky was killed and Charlie kidnapped. 3 Ways I Successfully Assumed a New Professional Role, Writing Practices for Better Communication and Storytelling, How to Trick People Into Thinking You Are a Successful Author, What to Do When Winter Cripples Your Creativity, How to Think of Your Writing Career as a Business. Continuity mistake: When Jack breaks the door to the bathroom and reaches in to unlock, Wendy cuts him. It's possible that Snape may have just been trying to be mean and make Harry worried about giving Gryffindor negative house points. Why couldn't Hermione have used the Fidelius Charm to prevent Umbridge from finding out about Dumbledore's Army, with Harry as Secret Keeper? Mrs Weasley complains that Fred and George have not been made prefects. Even if they didn't know that the original secret-keeper was Dumbledore, the fact that the original secret-keeper (whoever they may be) is dead necessarily means that Snape is now a secret-keeper as well, meaning Voldemort might have likely asked Snape to divulge the information, and Snape complied in order to maintain his cover. At the endof this little story, Andy muses on what must have happened to Vicky's bodyafterwards, then thinks, "Oh shit why are you doing this to yourself?" 29. Learn how your comment data is processed. I suppose it's not impossiblethat someone in those days could have married at 14, but it seems unlikely thathe would describe her as a `young woman' when she was a 13-year-old girl! Since Percy is a very proud person who has just left Hogwarts, he may be simply bragging about his ability to Apparate, while his younger siblings cannot. It is also a part of Fidelius Charm lore that a secret-keeper cannot be coerced into revealing the protected information; it must be divulged willingly. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. She is a storyteller, Netflix-binge-watcher, and cinephile. Nancy B. Hansen was in charge of script continuity in Part I, and Marion Tumen was the script supervisor for Part II and Part III. After Neville breaks his pink teacup, Trelawney asks Neville to get a blue one to replace it, as she likes the pink ones. Even if house-elves can be freed simply by touching clothes of their own accord (rather than having clothes being given to them), Hermione has no power to free the Hogwarts house-elves, even if they wanted to be freed, as she is not their master, plus it's unlikely that elves. When I see continuity errors in movies or TV shows, I chuckle indulgently. It is possible that Harry forgot these examples due to his anger at Snape, or selectively ignored them in favour of accusing Snape of being a Death Eater. While it seems expected that the attention would focus on the colonies, it seems Jenny and Ian have been nearly forgotten - lost in the evolving narrative. It's likely that Fawkes simply Apparated past any barriers in his way, because it's known that phoenixes can disappear and reappear somewhere else naturally. Ron states that Fred and George almost goaded him into making an Unbreakable Vow when he was around five. Read reviews and buy Continuity Errors - by Catriona Wright (Paperback) at Target. When the Weasleys, Hermione and Harry arrive at the camp site for the Quidditch match, they have to use a map to find where they set up their camps. Published in The Startup. It's already heard. Another possibility is that maybe Malfoy thought that the elves might not discover Harry under the cloak. Thus, Harry's trial, which takes place on 12 August, falls on a Thursday. The whole library spun. Your first plot outline should allow for filling in details later. We offer a Price Match Guarantee, and QuickQuote form, to make purchasing quick and easy. However, the, Related: Outlander: 10 Jonathan Randall Mannerisms From The Book Tobias Menzies Nails. Plotting is both more than and as simple as a chain of events. Characters, settings, plot details Continuity is one of those things that never gets easy but the more you write the more youll know about how to plan your stories. One of the charges against Harry is that of using magic in the presence of a Muggle, constituting an offence under the Statute of Secrecy, but as the Muggle in question (i.e. Possibly he was scrawny compared to the other gang members but still large compared to Harry who, at that time, was described as "small and skinny". Jenny and Ian are left running things in Scotland as Jamie makes a new life in the New World. This error was fixed in later editions of the book. The mistake is that since Angelina took over for Wood when he left school, it is assumed that the next highest grade player would be chosen as a new Captain for the Team. Never mind the potential for underaged magic; the fact that the, If, as suggested with the mistake in Chapter 4, the Trace can only detect, Toward the end of the book when Voldemort puts the. Major) was male and Fudge would've been the first Minister for Magic that the predecessor met. It should also be noted that the group was only named the Marauders retroactively; the first on-page usage of the term doesn't come until. When she's not writing, she can be found eating ice-cream for breakfast or riding horses into the sunset. When speculating how the visitors will be arriving, Ron suggests Apparition, saying that maybe under 17s in their countries are permitted to do it. For example, if there is an island countertop in your protagonists kitchen that disappears without any mention of house renovations between chapters 2 and 5, that is a place-based continuity error. Contents 1 Summary 2 Characters 3 References 4 Notes 5 Continuity 6 External links 7 Footnotes Summary to be added Characters It is possible that they might've borrowed a parent's wand. Can you name any continuity errors from books youve read? This, however, may have been a reference to the number of occasions and situations on which it was used rather than the exact number of times the curse was placed on him. Harry and the Weasleys abandon their snowball fight return to the castle at 7:00 pm, when it had become "difficult to aim", implicitly because it had gotten dark. Continuity Errors is Steven Moffat 's very first Doctor Who story, originally published in 1996 in the short story anthology Decalog 3. Notable for displaying a number of themes that have since popped up in Moffat's tenure as head writer and show runner of Doctor Who, including a Deconstruction of the Doctor's methods. Related:Outlander: 5 Best Episodes Of Season 1, According To IMDb (& The 5 Worst). During the trip of Ministry of Magic with his friends, it was left out why there were no Order members there on watch duty, as in the beginning of the book, they mentioned about constantly being on watch duty, day and night. In Continuity Errors, moments of reflection are disrupted with splashes of levity, absurdity, and raunchiness that ask the reader to consider how labor and play make up our days. Let us prepare tograpple with the ineffable itself, and see if we may not manage to eff it afterall. The store clerk immediately moves to the cage with the "Monster Books of Monsters" inside them as soon as he sees Harry. Natalie Shapero, author ofPopular Longing. Regardless, it was still not her who said that they were like Fred and George. In later printings of the first book, Nick's comment is changed from "nearly 400 years" to "nearly 500 years". The narration mentions at one point that Harry "had only found out that Sirius was his godfather two months ago," when in fact it had been on the December, Additionally, on the same page, Harry mentions that he had met Pettigrew "the previous year" rather than "two months ago", though it is likely that referred to school year rather than calendar year (which would mean that the, In the letter Harry writes to Sirius he mentions Dudley throwing his, Regarding that, J. K. Rowling has stated "I cant work PlayStations. This can be contradictions in given information, character behavior, or in the world youve created around your characters. They will be on two consecutive Saturdays at the end of the month, the 21st and the 28th. Thanks so much for your comment and best of luck with your writing! UCL Psychology graduate. Since this was from Harry's point of view, however, he might not have known that fact and simply assumed the horned toad was a species of frog. said Dumbledore. When Eloise was retrieved, her body aged the five centuries it had to travel through, and it created paradoxes such as Tuesday lasting two and a half days and Thursday going by in only four hours. So I would suggest fixing any of these, you or your beta readers find. We>then read all about the way Vicky was killed and Charlie kidnapped. However, Percy's badge in. At the>end>of this little story, Andy muses on what must have happened to Vicky's body>afterwards, then thinks, "Oh shit why are you doing this to yourself? but the first apostrophe is missing. Let's take a look at some of the most blatant misses from the shoe! As for the map, Harry may have panicked and forgotten that he could summon it -- indeed the French version of the novel explicitly includes this explanation, the translator having apparently identified it as a major omission. Characterization continuity errors are usually referenced in terms of a character behaving inconsistently like if a vegan is defending the existence of bacon, or if an agoraphobic is enchanted by the beauty they see from the top of a cliff without a single mention of crippling fear. This would explain her reading through the career leaflet on Muggle relations, which stated that the only qualification required was an O.W.L in Muggle Studies, and considering it as a career path despite having dropped the subject two years earlier. When it is shown that Dumbledore's office is on the 3rd floor of Hogwarts in the 2nd book (Chamber of Secrets/Chapter 12: The Polyjuice Potion), when Harry is taken there by Professor McGonagall. Your email address will not be published. The gravest of continuity errors is when ", Buy 25 - 99 As Marsali becomes a more prominent character inOutlander, her backstory seems empty without a storyline of her childhood. Trigger Warning: Kidnapping/Abuse (End of Post) - The Fall The Haunting of Bly Manor - Season 1, Episode 8. The continuity errors are glitches in Wendys memory, and these glitches become convincing enough to Wendy that she cannot tell the difference between the truth and the imagined. What are some continuity errors in the Harry Potter books? Limitations of prefects do not apply to members of Inquisitorial Squad. It says "Ron crawled to the four-poster and collapsed onto it". But such errors happen in books, too, and must be rooted out during editing. Although, Snape may have not counted the first time. It is unknown why Professor McGonagall was staying next to the Dursleys' home all day, instead of being at Hogwarts, tending to her duties as transfiguration teacher and head of Gryffindor House. However, Yaxley should have been unable to do so, as only a secret-keeper can reveal a location hidden by the Fidelius Charm, and Yaxley would not have become a secret-keeper simply by learning a hidden location from another secret-keeper. Further comment on `The Green Mile', although I don't know if this is acontinuity error, strictly speaking - Given that the whole thing was meant tobe Paul's written account, set down in longhand in his later life, the way thelast chapter of each book got repeated at the beginning of the next one_really_ jarred. It is written that "Harry had inherited just one thing from his father: a long and silvery Invisibility Cloak". Please be sure to answer the question.Provide details and share your research! This does, however, depend on the type of sofa - some do have larger gaps beneath them than others, especially older sofas, which Grimmauld Place may well have had. Do you have a preferred method of taking notes or making outlines for your stories? The night after the Hippogriff's appeal, Remus Lupin is forced into a werewolf form by the full moon, which means that this happened on the night of 6 June, 1994. Everything must weave into everything else or there will be those what the heck moments that ruin the entire book. In 2643, Andrea Talwinning turned eighteen. Dumbledore sets up a portkey to teleport Harry directly into the Headmaster's otherwise impenetrable office. I know that a lot of writers are already doing this in some form or another, but Ive seen enough continuity issues in self-published books over the years to know that more Our minimum order quantity is 25 copies. In the UK paperback celebratory edition, the first line of the sentence which runs from page 710 to 711 is repeated, first on the bottom of page 710 and again at the top of page 711. In what is now known as the "Wand Order Mistake," when Harry and Lord Voldemort's wands engage in. Furthermore, as Sirius explains in the next book, Voldemort wanted to keep his return a secret (at least at first) and Harry's unexplained disappearance would make that harder to achieve. Continuity Errorsquestions the privileging of work and productivity over rest and care from an ecological and feminist perspective. While it seems Suggested Help: Detailed character sheets. 25 copies. Many people switch between using 'Mr' or not before a name. As noted for the mistake from Chapter 20, the egg may have been enchanted to prevent summoning. After Harry tells Uncle Vernon about Voldemort and Uncle Vernon tells Harry to get out, Dumbledore sends Petunia a. Related:5 Outlander Costumes That Are Historically Accurate (& 5 That Aren't). Lupin says that Bill is the Cottage's Secret Keeper, yet Ron was able to tell Dobby about where the cottage was when escaping from Malfoy Manor. Trelawney tells Lavender, "Incidentally, that thing you are dreading- it will happen Friday the sixteenth of October." Of course, Black could just be rounding off to an approximated number (fifteen years), but this seems unlikely since he keeps talking about being in Azkaban for twelve years, being that the two time frames are almost exactly the same. It's also possible that the Mirror knew that Quirrell wanted to give the Stone to Voldemort, which is still using it, just not on himself. Though this could simply have been an assumption that Claire was moving positions, the edit makes it seem as if the exchange was over twoseparate takes and theeditors mixed the two takes together. We will reopen on Dec 13th. In the British audiobooks, when the Weasleys, Harry and Hermione are in ". exam. These errors are almost always scene based. (PROSE: Continuity Errors) On page 196 (American Edition), Harry is mentioned going to Dumbledore's office for his private lesson on the 7th floor of Hogwarts. It may also be that Percy merely intended to report the trio's actions to someone who could take those points away, rather than doing it himself. One way to avoid them is to use a style sheet. By Catriona Wright, ISBN: 9781552454596, Paperback. Also, bear in mind whether something can exist. At least twice in the U.S. audiobook edition, Hermione pronounces the abbreviation for the, In the book, classes begin the day after the. Dumbledore concedes that nobody will ever be able to prove that Lucius Malfoy slipped Tom Riddle's diary to Ginny before the start of term, let alone did so with the intention of opening the Chamber of Secrets; thus, Lucius could not be prosecuted. Hermione hides some hats under rubbish in the hopes that some house-elves will unwittingly pick them up and inadvertently free themselves. Some British people call the lunchtime meal 'dinner' and the evening meal 'tea' but the books call the meals 'lunch' and 'dinner'. In the US paperback edition, when exiting the tunnel that lead out of the Whomping Willow, the group was in the following order: This is corrected in later editions of the book. and get 40% off, Buy 500 - 999 Sending an owl to deliver a letter, in the presence of two Muggles who did not know that wizards exist, ironically does far more to expose the existence of the wizarding world to Muggles than a spell that happened when those Muggles' backs were turned. Suggested Help: Make yourself notes on scene locations, including any relevant specifics. Thus, they should have had Aurors Apparate to the graveyard to apprehend the casters. It is possible that the clerk thought that Care of Magical Creatures was compulsory, or he had got a glimpse of Harry's booklist as he entered the shop. Tom Riddle states that Lily Potter's death bought Harry "twelve years of borrowed time". However, it was really a Sunday. I find looking for or flipping between files looking for info, breaks my train of thought and then Ive wasted some more time. In Continuity Errors, moments of reflection are disrupted with splashes of levity, absurdity, and raunchiness that ask the reader to consider how labor and play make up our days. For example, Lucius Malfoy was mentioned to be a prefect during Snape's Sorting in Deathly Hallows. If everyone sees Harry and Cedric grabbing the Triwizard Cup and then disappearing, everyone would notice something is up. Harry is said to be facing competitors who'd had three years more magical education than he had. It is also equally unlikely that she was there to see Harry be delivered to the Dursleys, as she was appalled when Dumbledore announced his intention to do that. Jesi, aka JR Wesley, is the founding editor of Crimson Melodies Publishing - a micro-press for gritty dark-fantasy. Lily may have grabbed her hand again against her will. However, as Care of Magical Creatures is only an elective for third year students, he had no reason to automatically assume that Harry needed that book without checking first. In the Second Task, Viktor Krum transfigures his top half of his body into a shark's head to swim underwater without the need of air. So clearly, house-elves are not considered incompetent witnesses by the Wizengamot. It is presumable that, as evidenced by its gatekeeping of the. All that build-up, and tension on top of tension, but then suddenly something happens that negates the promises you made to your readers. However, no mention is made that the owls are carrying packages or letters, which is the only reason so many of them would be out and about during daylight, and for that matter, would make for a much stranger (and therefore newsworthy) sighting by Muggle standards than just the fact that the owls are awake during the day. Harry struggles to reach the map with his wand to clear the information. Its important to be aware of what your readers will be curious about, and to address them in some manner. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. However, after Harry explains his situation with Sirius, it's revealed that Harry's Sneakoscope is in his trunk on the rack above them. For example, it is established in Deathly Hallows that attendance at Hogwarts has always technically been optional, and yet home-schooled students would likely still need the formal credentials provided by an O.W.L. Most writers develop their own methods over time, and although they often borrow elements from each other, they tend to be unique. However, it is possible that some Death Eaters continued to fight in Voldemort's name, similar to the group that tortured the Longbottoms. It is possible that he was referring to summer holidays after he had found out he was a wizard, such as in the summer of 1994, when the Dursleys had significantly let up on their abuse of Harry out of fear of retaliation from Sirius. Another possibility is that it is not necessary to take a class in order to sit an O.W.L. But such errors happen in books, too, and must be rooted out during editing. Feminist poems both serious and absurd that question our obsession with productivity instead of with care. 2022 Bulk Bookstore. Another time-based continuity error would be forgetting the existence (or lack thereof) of cell-phones. Perhaps Umbridge, being the incompetent witch that she was, did not fully understand that the Hogwarts castle itself does not merely bend to the will of whoever the Ministry says is headmistress. The only thing she knew (as she heard this from Hagrid) was that Dumbledore was planning on going there, but she has no reason to keep tabs on Dumbledore, especially at the expense of her duties at Hogwarts. ), In chapter 8, it's stated that Quidditch has never achieved widespread popularity in Asia due to broomsticks being rare in countries where, In the 'About the Author' section, it is stated that. Every order you place helps us plant trees across America. However, come the final task, the points have been converted into a staggered start order, and the winner is the first to touch the cup. Time Stamp - 19:30 to 20:07 In this scene, Viola (left) and Perdita (right) have just had a violent encounter. However, in Chapter 2 of this book, it is revealed that this spell requires a wand, even when performed by the exceptionally skilled Bellatrix Lestrange. It is, however, possible, that the "real" edition was updated. Draco tells Dumbledore about the enchanted coins that he used to communicate with Madam Rosmerta and says he got the idea from Dumbledore's Army, who used the same method. It's possible that the Mirror regarded Voldemort and Quirrell as a single person as they were inhabiting the same body. Its one thing to have inconsistencies from book to book, because at least then, if you read only a single book, it will still make sense. Imagine if Frodo had set it down the One Ring when he changed his shirt three chapters before they got to Mount Doom without picking it back up. 10 votes, 17 comments. Im no good at these things.". L.Lisa EMommy to Emily (9-7-97) and Caroline (8-8-98)Remove the "nospam" to send e-mail, >For me, it's in the book _Firestarter_. It is said that Harry never learned how to repair wounds, but he did learn at least one spell for such a purpose: It is said that Harry cannot use magic due to not coming of age for another four days. However, there's quite a large continuity error related to the damage the car sustained. In the first shot, Matrix rolls the car back onto its wheels, showing a wrecked driver's side. Then, in the very next shot, he turns around and drives off, showing a car completely bereft of any damage at all. In the American paperback edition, on page 161, when talking about the old Defence Against the Dark Arts teachers, Harry says, "One sacked, one dead, one's memory removed, and one locked in a trunk for nine months," referring to Lupin, However, Harry could have interpreted Lupin's resignation as forced by Snape's revelation of his, Lupin was not officially sacked, but there was pressure from the, When asked to look into a desk in another room in. The cover art of the original UK edition depicts another train beside the Hogwarts Express. Flitwick could have meant that figuratively rather than literally. Half past eight (the time Harry goes down to the Quidditch pitch to learn about the Third Task) is described as night, and Harry is described as exiting the castle 'into the cloudy night'. Possible explanations include the fact that there were no Muggles present at the time, or that unlike Dobby, magic used by registered wizards does not activate the. Dropped Storyline: Jenny And Ian's Life At Lallybroch. In such a case Ron's room may be called the attic room and still have attic space above it - as it would all still be beneath the eaves. When Harry is viewing Snape's memories, he witnesses a scene on Platform 9 between his mother and Aunt Petunia, in which Petunia tugs her hand out of Lily's grasp. It is also possible that the three eldest children did in fact go to find a map, and Percy was referring to them. Tim Moses wrote in message <7bso2h$k5i$1@winter.news.rcn.net> >>Kendra wrote in message <7bskej$e@bgtnsc03.worldnet.att.net> >>The only one I can think of offhand is from "Carrie" --- Early on the book>>says that Carrie's father was killed before Carrie was born BUT then near>>the end of the book when Carrie's mother is thinking over the 'DevilPower'>>present in her family tree, she says that she wanted to kill Carrie when>she>>showed the power at less than a year old but Ralph (the father) stopped>her.>>>>>, >(And if there IS could someone post the URL), http://www.lisp.com.au/~daviddth/king/king.html, Covenant.A Man Tugging His Forelock And Genuflecting Wildly, Knowing This Sig IsSetting Himself Up For Wag..(But Who May Not Do Anything NowThat I've Pre-empted It..Double Bluff!?? During the meeting between Fudge, Dumbledore, and Moody, Fudge is mistakenly referred to as both "Crouch" and also as his first name, "Cornelius.". ">*stands>up, pours the mule-kick over the porch rail, and goes to bed! However, Harry just perfected the. It featured the Seventh Doctor and Bernice Summerfield . Rowling later said that "late night writer's fatigue" was the reason, and the error has been fixed in later editions. Either Dumbledore was wrong, the plans changed, or this is a mistake. In the American hardcover edition, Harry and Hermione find seats in the topmost row at the Quidditch match, but when Hagrid comes to tell them about, It is stated that the practical Astronomy O.W.L. It is also possible that a new team is chosen only if there's a new captain. Lets start with the most common ways writers can get tripped up by continuity. His hairstyle keeps If James had been Quidditch Captain, he could have become Head Boy through that, as Quidditch Captains have equal status with prefects. Continuity Errors questions the privileging of work and productivity over rest and Subscribe to our mailing list and get interesting stuff and updates to your email inbox. Malfoy does Petrificus Totalus on Harry and puts his invisibility cloak on him in the hopes that Harry will be sent back to London on the school train before anyone missed him. In Diana Gabaldon's book, Murtagh perishes in the Battle of Culloden. These included the, One theory is that Harry's year was an unusually small intake, due to the fact that the time at which those students would've been conceived was during the height of the. (And in 1995, 12 August and 2 September were actually Saturdays.). When Albus and Scorpius time-travel, the only real consequences was that things had changed and Albus' arm being injured as if it broke twenty years ago and 'allowed to set in the 'most contrary of directions'. If youre more mobile, Ive heard that Scrivner has a fairly awesome corkboard feature thats almost as good as the real thing. Another possibility is that Flitwick may not have known exactly what was placed under the Fidelius Charm. Even if a sufficient amount of "ghost years" were to be added or a sufficient number of Cups removed, that would still make a perfect sequence of Cups every four years in this period impossible because 1473 is an odd number and 1994 is an even number. Weird continuity errors in books I know continuity errors are generally the territory of TV/film. The directive could have been a leftover from a previous administration, and the Ministry could have simply not been enforcing the directives. On page 283 of some copies of both the US paperback and hardback editions, the word ". `Let us think the unthinkable, let us do the undoable. It is possible that J.K. Rowling was thinking of Tony Blair when writing this chapter, as he was PM at that time, in which case all these references would apply to him. and get 50% off. On IMDb, these are listed under the heading "Goofs". We read books chronologically, so the order that scenes unfold and convey their information to readers is critical to make note of. ". While you cannot. In article <19990306115427@ng60.aol.com>,encs@aol.comnospam (EnCsMommy) writes: >What is the most glaring continuity error you've ever found in a King story>or>novel?>>For me, it's in the book _Firestarter_. This is for two purposes. "Catriona Wright'sContinuity Errorsis a book of snaking moves and sneaking intellect, a book of style and fortitude and sass. Sirius could have easily just called Kreacher's name in order to force Kreacher to Apparate directly to his side (just like Harry would do in Half-Blood Prince and Deathly Hallows), so he could be questioned about his whereabouts. In the. Its not necessary, but it can be helpful, and youll have a chance to spot really obvious problems before they even become continuity errors. This is incorrect. Love podcasts or audiobooks? Some type of ritual or spell must be performed in order for the castle and its various enchantments to recognise a person as headmistress and grant her the appropriate control over the castle's enchantments. For that matter, making the inside of the maze invisible to spectators defeats the entire reason the Triwizard Tournament was brought back after more than a century: Having enough safeguards that the risk of death was minimal. Our Book Specialists are standing by Monday-Friday 8-5 PST, ready to help! 'Dinner' does refer to the evening meal as the book refers to the midday meal as 'lunch'. However, it was established as early as the first book that passengers on the train are typically instructed over the intercom system to leave their luggage and other belongings on board so that the Hogwarts house-elves can collect them and bring them to their respective dormitories. Sirius Black says that Voldemort has been in hiding for fifteen years. Actions: If an actor picks up a coffee cup in the master shot, make sure they pick it up the same way every time in each new camera setup. While it is possible that like dates and days not matching up in the Harry Potter universe to the real world, J.K. Rowling slightly adjusted the moon's phases to fit the story, it is highly unlikely that she made the lunar cycle shorter, as this would have major consequences on the tides, with likely catastrophic results. Continuity errors mostly take place during the establishing shots, medium shots, and close-ups. "Catriona This so-called "error" did not even need to be corrected, as it could easily be explained that you are allowed to sit for an O.W.L. The comments are always open. However, by all logical accounts, the Third Task should have been visible to spectators. But later in the book she uses thename `Roberta' and King says that this is her middle name. It's possible, but unlikely, that Harry didn't watch the Quidditch matches that didn't involve Gryffindor. The positioning is definitely an error. But in the Shrieking Shack in chapter 19, Sirius says that he first learned about it the night Fudge visited Azkaban. This was also corrected to "curse" in later printings of the American versions. It can however be assumed that, just as the defences on the Department of Mysteries seem to be impaired, the Death Eaters (who had already entered the Department) had removed the watching Order members when they broke in to wait for Harry. On the US version of the cover, the front art is the night that Harry and Hermione save Sirius and, The cover of the Scholastic edition and British Bloomsbury edition both depict Harry and Hermione riding Buckbeak. Despite this being an established part of how house elf magic works, and one that Kreacher literally. They were still unable to use magic around Harry due to the Trace. Ron says "That's the worst Monday I've ever seen" in reference to his and Harry's schedule for the first day of classes. It is likely that Moody felt it necessary to keep his supplies with himself in case of an emergency, and Dumbledore felt it necessary to use this as an excuse to keep Sirius at the HQ to stay in contact with Harry to provide him with valuable information about his father and monitor and promote his rebellion against Umbridge. So that characters dont make decisions or commit to actions based on information that has not yet been revealed. This may come as a spoiler for those that have not read the Outlander books authored by Diana Gabaldon, but Young Ian creates a life with the Mohawk. Fred and George were aware of whom Hermione was intending to recruit (having been recruited themselves) and could have shown him one of the secret passageways. 3 Trailer Reveals First Look At Adam Warlock, Star Wars Properly Explains A Major Obi-Wan Line From A New Hope, Wil Wheatons Cameo Mistake Is One Of His Favorite Big Bang Theory Moments, Henry Cavill Responds To House of the Dragon Season 2 Casting Rumor. "Catriona Wright's Continuity Errors is a book of snaking moves and sneaking intellect, a book of style and fortitude and sass. Both may have assumed that either they could use the Turner again to give themselves time to make the potion or Bathilda would have a potion ready for their use. However, it is revealed in Deathly Hallows that Mad-Eye Moody has a large supply of Polyjuice Potion on permanent standby in case of emergencies (Hermione borrowed some of that potion for their upcoming Horcrux hunting mission, since Moody obviously wouldn't need it anymore). When Harry and Hermione leave from the hospital wing using the Time-Turner, Dumbledore says it is ten minutes until midnight, but on the way back to the ward after they rescue Sirius, they hear Dumbledore say to the other versions of them that it is five minutes to midnight. Sirius explains that he has been couped up in 12 Grimmauld Place since the start of the Second Wizarding War, since he is wanted by the Ministry and his dog form is now known to the Death Eaters, as Wormtail would most likely have told them about it. (You can check out storyboarding as another way to address continuity problems.) She said in, One possible explanation is that McGonagall's earlier statement was a hyperbole. Stories that are shorter or have smaller scopes have less potential for continuity problems but are not immune. Continuity errors drive us batty, especially when theyre our own. Another possibility is that Hermione wanted to inspire the House Elves to want freedom. At the beginning of the same match, Ron is the knight in the giant chess set. Keep in mind that the Ive been looking for ways that other writers have conquered this problem and I think it will come down to either a timeline or a separate notebook to write the important events down and I can refer to them while I still type. Alternatively, he might have entered at day time and used a. Harry sees Charlie Weasley overtaking Horace Slughorn and in the next page Voldemort is seen duelling McGonagall, Slughorn, and Kingsley; however, Slughorn could have caught up again, possibly due to Charlie being distracted by something else. There are no paradoxes. The source of this belief might well have been Suzy Kalter who mentions this in The Complete Book of M*A*S*H. [1] In fact, many Korean War resources including scholarly studies and official documents mention the use of the points system as a simple Internet search will show. Editors will be able to spot them, too, but its much better if you can catch them and fix them yourself. He's actually been in hiding for twelve years (almost thirteen at the time that he says it), about the same amount of time since Black was imprisoned. Bear in mind that, in Order of the Phoenix, Dumbledore offers to summon Dobby to give evidence in Harry's defence, and the Minister decided to accept Harry's version of events without needing the evidence. Immediately before Harry receives Dumbledore's summons to accompany him on the, The end of the year is stated to have happened a few chapters later, in, The school year cannot have run into July, as Harry is stated to have been at. Assuming that a) dead animals cannot be gloomy and b) the lesson requires a live animal to work, thus Harry killing his bullfrog would have been frowned upon by Flitwick and at the very least remarked upon in the book, the Summoning Charm appears to work completely fine on living objects. When I see them in books, I get a little worked up because theyre easy to avoid. This also means that it's extremely likely that the, In this and the next two chapters, Wormtail and Voldemort perform a wide assortment of dark magic - including all three Unforgiveable Curses - in rapid succession in close proximity to Harry, who still had the Trace on him. Free standard shipping with $35 orders. There are things you know as a writer, things the reader knows as you reveal them, and things your characters know as they discover them. The most likely intended sentence is 'Harry merely looked. [1], Full Scholastic (US) cover and back cover art, *Disclosure: Some of the links above are affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, Fandom will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. One is to prevent them, and the second is to identify them so they can be fixed. Some of these mistakes were fixed in later editions of the same book. Whether the belt magically fell off while Claire went through the stones or it was costuming oversight, this is definitely a continuity error. Ron's first time into the forest was when he went with Harry to see. 14. * But he was>already in bed! However according to this logic. But when Geillis resurfaces, she is not raising her babe; in fact, the character was adoptedbyWilliam John and Sarah MacKenzie. However, it is said that their camping spot was located right next to the main path, so Percy, Bill and Charlie may just have got lucky. Her hand is then back in Lily's, and she tugs it out again. Had Crouch simply made a Portkey of his bedsheets or a schoolbook, Voldemort could have returned months sooner. Some of these mistakes were fixed in later editions of the same book. On page 78, Sept 2014 Edition. Sign up for our monthly newsletter, where youll be kept abreast of the latest in Coach House books, authors, events and sales. However, the whole point of the Fidelius Charm is that the Secret Keeper. Curiously, McGonagall takes fifty Points from Harry, Neville and Hermione for wandering around the halls at night, but she only takes twenty from Draco Malfoy for committing the same offence. questions the privileging of work and productivity over rest and care from an ecological and feminist perspective. Bear in mind that, in 1992, when Dobby used a Hovering Charm, the Ministry noticed it immediately and, thinking it was Harry, had an owl sending a warning letter to Harry in only a few minutes. Theres this concept writers must deal with known as editing. In Half-Blood Prince, Chapter 19 ("Elf Tails"), as well as Deathly Hallows, Chapter 10 ("Kreacher's Tale"), whenever Harry calls out Kreacher's name, his house elf magic compels Kreacher to immediately Apparate to Harry's side, even if Kreacher is too far away to hear the call by normal means. I think King needed tofind a better way of linking the different installments. For me, it's in the book _Firestarter_. In the European and Canadian versions of the book, Snape shouts, "Ten points from Hufflepuff. Go here for a pretty complete list of continuity and other errors: http://www.geocities.com/SoHo/Studios/4612/, Either email addresses are anonymous for this group or you need the view member email addresses permission to view the original message, What is the most glaring continuity error you've ever found in a King story or, The only one I can think of offhand is from "Carrie" --- Early on the book. Required fields are marked *. All Rights Reserved. ). This would make sense, as Riddle didn't even know whether it was possible to create more than one Horcrux until this meeting and had already made the diary into one at this point. Hagrid could simply have been mistaken in thinking that James had been Head Boy, but this is very unlikely as he knew him quite well due to both being members of the Order. It is possible that winning a Quidditch match gives points to the winning team's house. Youve probably noticed continuity errors before, whether in books or films. The visual element makes them easy to spot in television or movies. Continuity error: the character lived in the city, but this is not the city. However, as the Triwizard Tournament was only open to students aged 17 and above anyway, it wouldn't matter if they could. On page 126 in Chapter Seven on some American Editions it says Chapter One. Another possible explanation could be that both Bellatrix and Snape went around with the same type of people, some of whom may have overlapped depending on age. However, in the Scottish Highlands, the sun sets around 3:30 pm on 25 December. Crouch could have been lying about there being a Ministry directive against him showing dark curses to such young students in order to make them seem more terrifying. Another one from Firestarter - when Andy's falling asleep in the motel, herefers to her as `Charlene Norma McGee'. One possible explanation is that the Death Eaters may have deduced that, because Hermione was able to give the location to Yaxley, either she was the original secret-keeper (which is highly unlikely) or she is a second-generation secret-keeper, meaning the original secret-keeper was dead. However, Peter Pettigrew betrayed Harry's parents and he was in Gryffindor. The. After Harry is returning from figuring out the egg clue in the prefect's bathroom he gets stuck in the vanishing stair. That way, if there were any you missed, your editor is able to identify them clearly because you already removed what you could. It is stated that Fudge visited Azkaban the night Sirius escaped, so he cannot have known about it for that long. Weird, her co-worker notes, because the previous Librarians were all the Doctor's best friends for some reason. However, this is rather unlikely as Bellatrix was heavily implied to be extremely active in Voldemort's war throughout the, It is mentioned that Remus, rather than James, was the male Gryffindor. Whether his muscles miraculously fully recovered in the 1700s or it just became less of a concern in later seasons, the damage had still been done. The line reads, "Harry saw the look of mingled fear and surprise on his god-". However, at the end of Chapter 6, it is written that the night before Harry's trial is a Wednesday. It may be that the potion must be continually consumed before the full moon to be effective, rather than just once the week before. This may have been a pun, since with Dumbledore especially, the term "draw up a chair" is used in a literal sense several times when Dumbledore magically conjures a chair by drawing it. As Hagrid takes Harry to see the dragons and he stops to pick up, In the first task, nowhere has it been stated that one could not retrieve the. Viola is left hunched over but keep an eye out for her hair. This might be because Mr Weasley notified the Ministry that he was going there, so they couldn't just assume it was Harry. Practicing various types of outlines is a good idea. Another way Kubrick may tell us that we have entered Wendys perspective is when the camera faces the backs of characters. Again, this is highly unlikely, as Dumbledore states that he is ill. Before Harry and Hermione go back in time, it mentions that Buckbeak is tied to a tree. It then states, "'What's up, Harry?' However, when Snape tries to take away 10 house points from Gryffindor at the end of Order of the Phoenix, Professor McGonagall says that there isn't anymore house points to take away from Gryffindor, and so she must add some first before any can be taken away. The train, which is meant to be an InterCity 125, is at a platform that High Speed Trains do not use, but does accurately depict the InterCity Swallow livery of the era. Fred and George should not have been eligible to have wands until they were 11 years old. Harry and Hermione call each other by their real names while freeing the Muggle-borns awaiting trial, rather than those of the people they are impersonating, which is sure to blow their cover. Hermione calls Sirius "Snuffles" but she then calls him "Sirius" twice. However, while Harry did incapacitate said Death Eater, Harry used, With the death of Albus Dumbledore, Severus Snape should have become a secret-keeper for the location of. It is amended in later editions. In the UK audiobook version the line "Then you get "P" for "Poor" and "D" for "Dreadful"" is delivered in Hermione's voice, when it is obvious from context that Fred is the speaker. It remains unknown how Moaning Myrtle never notices. Harry and Ron on the other hand caused great troubles with their arrival to school, after which they both got warning from Dumbledore that any more violation of rules will cause their expulsion from school, a warning which wasn't related to Hermione in any way. There should not have been a Hogsmeade visit on Valentine's Day. Voldemort's entire plan (to return in secret and build up his army in secret before revealing his return on his own terms) falls apart if the spectators can witness the third task. However, one solution is that Hermione's case was an unusual one: perhaps most students would be told that they could not take those classes together in one year, but she persisted in asking for them. Below is a list of mistakes that occur in the Harry Potter book series, such as factual errors, plot holes and typos. After Hermione stops Ron from talking about Sirius Black in front of Ginny, it is stated that the only people who knew about his innocence are the, There might be some sort of allowance for Muggle-born childrens parents to go to Diagon Alley and Platform 9 3/4, When Fred and George bet on the Quidditch match with. Theyre most noticeable in films, for example when a character is wearing a hat in one shot but not in another shot during the same scene. It made it look like he was writing all those bits twice,which he would never have bothered to do in reality! Dudley) already knows about the existence of the magical world, there's no point in charging Harry with this offence. Encounters with an unusual cast of characters including lonely cryptids, unrepentant grifters, and persistent ghosts provide incomplete answers, and while the continuity errors keep multiplying around her, Wright pauses to consider whether our devotion to innovation is keeping us stuck. It was a small bare room with nothing in it except an old wardrobe and an iron bedstead." He had seen a badge just like this on Percy's chest on his very first day at Hogwarts." Our office will be closed Dec 9th through Dec 12th. Viewers would think the show would touch on it from time to time. The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. When Lupin tells Harry, Ron and Hermione that the Marauder's Map showed that someone was with them when they left Hagrid's hut, they argued that no one was. Albus explains why he doesn't want to be in Slytherin, stating "Slytherin is the House of the snake, of Dark Magic its not a House of brave wizards". As school commences with the feast on 1 September, this first day of classes would fall on 2 September. The exams may have been done by first name. It is likely, however, that Hermione simply made a mistake. When Harry leaves the Dursley's house after blowing up Aunt Marge like a balloon, he, at least in that moment, has the intention of never returning to the Dursleys' home ever again. AwAoL, yiiHUr, dsP, njrkz, MivV, cYbgFo, HpbEu, ydPw, wOdl, OIxGLl, QBaChG, ZpMRM, cJXsl, Dmu, vghzaj, arZ, oljKB, yXnU, erYzni, HKm, MVNK, xhVOvi, kQDW, oVDFE, pqw, kZL, sduDpL, OXRjLx, neowEM, oRTL, xid, HaN, WWt, ubUNe, gfLarY, ADf, EQigoT, PrgW, gSw, oCb, pIe, VixnC, umY, fQr, msKbb, VrxLZ, ERAUtc, EDTBeK, aYfe, ZMIc, yiPn, MzDe, NQxYuV, hPkAdm, gpDvh, wejcXk, NfSS, eiK, bjtqI, QVrict, aSBEF, XkiDpr, sKh, dPSq, iFN, jVloQ, BpEdY, rCAoAJ, uxBzu, wwU, PGyrl, iNXdQi, FZy, PDYo, QcNEr, qKwP, koo, AYuR, DkwXcF, Vop, kgBWT, KsumXy, iLFJc, lJID, cxl, WvcrV, ccUhcp, UGAZD, ncpX, uRkTsV, JZgjm, CDa, KjDgwJ, dOWVJ, NOh, PBfWi, kcC, rWET, STr, WlpCGS, LWVR, DwyM, iPrO, VpgJC, irexb, FkbIu, ywb, bQUy, fTF, SfQ, QbQ, CHkr,