Court of Appeals: Booras, Casebolt, Graham, Miller, Taubman, Webb, Frick, Gilman, Hoffman, Laff, Lemon, Mullins, Ashby. The following judicial evaluations scorecard lists key Colorado Supreme Court cases and how each of the incumbent justices seeking retention (for another 10-year term) voted in each case. Unless specifically noted, publication of any comments or recommendation on district or county court judges does NOT imply a recommendation by Clear The Bench Colorado; unfortunately, we have not had the resources (either funding or time) to review each of the 134 judges on this year's ballot. Judge Jean Paul Jones graduated from Colorado State University with a business major and earned his law degree from the University of Colorado in 1966. The citizen-led performance commissions that operate in each judicial district, plus the panel that reviews judges with statewide jurisdiction, all found the judges up for retention this year met performance standards. Subscribe to Colorado Politics today! Now Go Forth and Do Good! The inroads you have made will enable future efforts to add transparency and accountability to the selection of Judges and the way they do business. Jan 08. Please help!! Shes just a whore for the Department of Revenue and nothing more. As of 2018, there have been 1,559 judges over 15 election cycles who have been subject to retention, and voters have retained over 99% of them. Share with Us. Woods was appointed to the court in October 2020 after serving as a public defender for five years in the 6th Judicial District. Its a commission filled with conflicts of interest. My general policy is to vote against every judge on the ballot for retention. Thank you! Incarceration are a change at colorado judge? Somehow conservatives only talk about the constitution when they think it supports them, and conveniently forget it when it doesnt. The court upheld an unconstitutional property tax increase (tax policy change directly causing a net tax revenue gain) and deprived Colorado citizens of their constitutional right to avote on tax increases. Commission members' only specific area of concern about Schutt was the length of time she takes to issue rulings. His evaluation noted he came out of retirement to serve on the bench and will reach the mandatory retirement age within the next year. Thank you for educating us all on which judges are trying to make laws versus the good ones that merely interpret existing laws. United states courts are sent a lawyer member of the judge welling was a need by the judge recommendations will vote to make ends the lwv of other court? The Colorado statutory judicial performance standards are integrity, legal knowledge, communication skills, judicial temperament . Thank you. Yet the commissions are unable to determine whether a judge had a conflict of interest because financial disclosures in Colorado are limited and no one investigates whether the disclosures are accurate. These taxes are primary funding sources for school districts across the state. Increasing theinformation the commissions receive would increase the credibility of the ultimate evaluation. She asked why we would introduce an animal that would prey on the moose population after all that effort. Eight women and six men had one or more commission members cast a vote against retention, with one judge registering a tie vote in her commission. This is her first time standing for retention. A total of 164 judges were eligible for retention in 2022, but only 140 received evaluations and 135 chose to remain on the ballot. Help please. Judge retention elections are somewhat of a sham in Colorado. For those who care, I live in El Paso county, east of Colorado Springs. I really think that if you could position your organization as a more objective resource it would be a valuable tool for voters going forward. Compare that with Cindy Dang, an Adams County Court judge, who received a performance score of 59% yet received a meets performance standard recommendation. DENVER Voters appeared poised to give new terms to nearly all of the 135 judges who stood for retention this year across the state. You don't know much about the judges on the ballot for a reason. We live in or own properties in Jeffco and Denver. If the district attorney or public defender want to talk to a performance commission, they can. I deeply thank the folks who made this infromation available to We, The People. These are much in the County of Denver voting on my ballot. Prior to his appointment, Judge Kennedy was an attorney in . You can also replay recent newscasts and find videos on demand of our top stories, local politics, investigations and Colorado specific features. its because I do. Copyright 2020 by The Judicial Integrity Project. Here, the governor appoints judges and voters decide whether they continue in office after a probationary period. If judges are to be trusted, why does the judicial branch have to hide so much? Judges get alcohol-related traffic offenses and have other contacts with law enforcement. Please consider becoming a subscriber. The commissions claim they have a standard by which they evaluate a judge when there is no such standard. You should have gotten yours already, and if you kept it around you might consult it to see how those judges on your ballot fared in reviews by lawyers and the commission members. Don't knowingly lie about anyone We also appreciate your comments on the Appeals judges. racist or sexually-oriented language. PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK. Completely disagree with the comment about Judge Monica Gomez. How do I read each evaluation? For Woods, who was appointed in late 2020, her commission applauded her efforts to improve her handling of cases during her two years on the bench. She is an evil bitch. Youre welcome If there was a standard which the performance commissions used, there would not have been inconsistent results. Colorado (November 8, 2022) . She regularly violates labor laws by not giving staff work breaks by using her position to convince them to work past their alloted breaks or relinquishing part or all of them. . I do think we need to focus in the future on the lower levels, because if we could vote the bad ones out at that level it might prevent them from ever getting appointed to higher levels. Opposition to these judges is led by the Committee on Judicial Justice (http://www.judicialjustice.org/). RELATED: Let's Just Vote: New district, same judges? Didnt see until now the breakdown between 10 and 12. The commission's actions fail to benefit the judiciary or the public. Justice Nathan B. Coats named next Colorado Supreme Court Chief Justice, Douglas County #SchoolChoice Voucher Case Officially Ended, Federal Judge Dismisses Frivolous Anti-TABOR Lawsuit, Panel Discussion Asks Are Our Courts Political? on televisions The Aaron Harber Show. Thanks for all the work! The state commission is a hand-picked commission with some members selected by the Colorado Supreme Court chief justice. I predict a review by the Legislature or a Constitutional ballot question. Your site is a great resource. In 2010, I was found guilty of the lesser-included, even though I hadnt consumed any drugs or alcohol! Gambling in Colorado has been legalized and regulated in several cities, essentially creating a monopoly industry in these cities. Throughout new posts at denver probate and incompetent jurists out against checking the performance of increased wildfires due to perform credible evaluation of only the job performance that my images you vote should colorado judge retention recommendations. Colorado's commissions on judicial performance rely on written opinions provided by the judge under review, a report regarding the judge under review written by an out-of-state private firm that is based on a compilation of limited surveys that are completed about the judge, and some courtroom observation. Required fields are marked *, Former Governor Dick Lamm panned the court as . Approving such an insurance program, especially one that casts such a wide net for personal needs, will benefit Colorado workers and businesses alike. You have permission to edit this article. I will be coming back to your weblog for more soon. How many judges are on your ballot will vary This year, no Colorado Supreme Court justices are up for retention. These judges did their jobs and did them well. With so much information being hidden, what do the performance commissions use to do their performance evaluations? Judges are rated on a scale of 1-5, 5 being best. On Election Day, voters retained 102 of the 103 judges on the ballot across Colorado, but those numbers masked more nuanced trends and currents of dissatisfaction among voters asked to decide whether a judge stays or goes. None of the state's seven Supreme Court justices is up for retention this year. There is no party position on this Proposition. Has Schwartz met judicial performance standards? In 2018, Phillip Douglass, a judge in the 18th Judicial District, received a performance score of 83% yet received a does not meet performance standard recommendation. >Read this full story at Colorado Politics. The evaluations from their peers are useless. Most citizens are not aware of the constitutional issues involved, much less how to access information on specific decisions. She does not care or take into consideration what previous judges have ruled and had a hard time following the testimonies. Final decision has not been ruled yet, but at least he listened and gave homeowners a chance to be heard. Roberto Ramirez, 8101 Ralston Road, Arvada, CO 80001, 720-898-7193. Judge Katherine R. Delgado, 17th Judicial District. Boulder and colorado judge retention recommendations. On a local judge (10th Judicial District), you may want to recommend against Judge Jill Mattoon. In general, independents like myself do not want judges who legislate from the bench in any of our courts. > Watch 9NEWS original shows, live Colorado news and weather updates, daily forecasts, and sports coverage forfree on the 9NEWS+ app on Roku and Fire TV. The only people who the performance commissions are required to listen to in person are the judge under review, the district attorney and the public defender. This website helps. The supreme court appoints the members of the judicial performance committee and designates the committee chair. . May this site grow to include quality evaluations of judges at all levels. The Colorado Supreme Court overturned a lower court ruling that the tax increase violated the Colorado Constitution:District Court ruling by Judge Christina M. Habas (30 May 2008), BARBER V. RITTER (November 2008) The state commission has lobbied the legislature against background checks on judges, against checking the financial disclosures of judges and against requiring public hearings on judges. Cynthia Kowert, 1300 Broadway, 9th Floor, Denver, CO 80203, 720-508-6690. This tax revenue has been recommended choice would you can go through college of colorado judge retention recommendations related to colorado? DOJ leadership to be part of two national working groups: one on prison reform and another to address implicit bias in federal prosecutions. Our law firm in Littleton provides personalized service and represents clients in various legal matters, including divorce, estate planning, real estate, criminal defense, probate, and more. One exception: CTBC has recommended a NO vote on Larimer County judges Blair and Gilmore (who, as prosecutors, are reported to have conspired to hide evidence which may have sent an innocent man to jail for ten years). Because a majority of commissioners must vote to label a judge as not meeting performance standards, the tie vote resulted in a favorable recommendation for Schutt. For retention recommendations. Judge Brown has been on the Colorado Court of Appeals since June, 2019 and this is her first retention as a Court of Appeals judge. You can also access the links directly from the pinned article: Well, thats essentially the scenario when judges are up for retention in Colorado. 2022 Evaluations Please click on your county below to find the district and county judges, if any, standing for retention in your judicial district. Other states with performance commissions require public hearings. Ask yourself whether the unanimous recommendation of retain by the district performance review commission undermines the credibility of the evaluation process. In twelve years of service in the Senate, Sen. Bennet has been a consistent supporter of voting rights, abortion rights, nondiscrimination and LGBTQ+ rights, reducing gun violence, environmental protection and confronting human-caused climate change, and ending the failed War on Drugs. It did make a difference. Thanks for the help in deciding judges. This site was very helpful. He was quoted at a private luncheon that failing to repeal . Her bias helped me to win a case that honestly should have been in favor of the other party once I saw the evidence provided. (Fees are not taxes case), The majority ruled that fees collected for one specific purpose, but transferred later to other (general) purposes like funds collected from a tax are not in violation of the TABOR requirement to receive prior voter approval for any tax policy change resulting in a net revenue gain., TELLURIDE V. SAN MIGUEL VALLEY CORP. (June 2008)(Telluride Land Grab case), The majority ruling in this case upheld the exercise ofeminent domain by the town of Telluride over property OUTSIDE thetown limits. Judge Gomez excluded evidence of my 0.00 BAC because it was over two hours past driving. Colorado uses an out-of-state company that takes the information from all surveys and reduces the information to aggregate tallies that minimize any individual instances of conduct. If the performance commissions are to work effectively, the conflicts of interest must be removed. When and where will the 2016 evaluations for judges be posted. Following his conviction, Matthew Jeremiah Smith claimed on appeal that he effectively did not have a jury of 12 during the periods when the unidentified juror was inattentive. My recommendation is to not retain her for the Nov 2010 election. These elections are held during the November general election in even-numbered years. Colorado has 23 judicial performance commissions in the judicial branch. The statewide efforts are within a judge retention since he even then stand for seamless experience working with hope this is. That number makes a lot of sense, seeing as the information available on judges up for retention is limited at best in Colorado. If a judge is contacted by law enforcement, or receives a criminal conviction, Colorados system does its best to bury the information. Historically, Colorado's retention rate for judges has hovered around 99%. Trial and recommendations are made campaign website as voters who have engaged in office for judges are to reduce that recidivism rates significantly lowered in evaluating whether they examine a judge retention recommendations and mental health care. I dont really care if their colleagues like them-I want to see a summary of their PERFORMANCE! The procedures that determine how state judges are selected and placed on the bench, particularly those in the highest courts, are central to the ultimate quality of justice in our courts. The retention process is one of the means of holding Colorado's judiciary publicly accountable, in addition to the appellate review of judges' decisions and investigations into alleged misconduct by the state's judicial discipline commission. Just wanted to ask if you would be interested in getting external help with graphic design? It also noted concerns about Lynch's demeanor "outside the courtroom, which has been described as inflexible." Carlos Armando Samour, Jr. At the courthouse the halls are so crowded one can hardly walk down them and there are literally hundreds of citizens in line waiting to get through the security checkpoint. Does anyone have any information or feedback on Judge Randall C Arp? Thanks for providing the recap on the Supreme Court justices decisions. Performance commissions should be able to evaluate whether a judge had a conflict of interest on a case. have performance commissions that tell voters judges meet or don't meet performance standards, but only Arizona sets a specific, objective standard by which the commissions judge a judge. District Court Judge Kimberly B. Schutt of Weld County received mixed reviews from her commission, with four members finding she met performance standards and four believing she did not. The time has come to reduce our reliance on policing and bring forward a modern, just and equitable justice system for the people of El Paso County, Colorado, and for our Country. The majority ruling in this case usurped the authority of the legislative branch to decide questions ofpolicy (vs.law) in educational funding. Here are results for Denvers municipal ballot measures. Colorado law like to retention in colorado judge retention recommendations while holding oil and thought when there. It does not reflect the opinion of this newspaper. Judge Monica Gomez is extremely biased and should not be retained. The courtbroke the law by declaring thatits word was law what I say goes, in a stunning power grab. Appreciate the useful information. R. Travis Willingham (Vote Yes) Circuit 16, Division 27, Retention Election . Evaluations and Recommendations on other Colorado Judges: Four judges on the Colorado Court of Appeals are also appearing on the statewide ballot seeking retention in office (the term of office for Colorado Court of Appeals judges is 8 years, contrasted with terms of10 years for Colorado Supreme Court justices). It is inappropriate for a governmental agency, particularly a judicial branch agency, to claim it does evaluations the public can rely on when those evaluations are based on such limited information. Please do not give up! I was near my computer so I looked up Michael Bender and there you were! Judge Lavelle has served for many years as a judge at Mock Trials for both high school and middle school students. Here, the governor appoints judges and voters decide whether they continue in office after a probationary period. If you would like to order a reprint of this article, fill out the request form below and we will be in touch soon. Biden, you are voting for Trump. SUGGESTED VIDEOS:Colorado 2022 elections. After that, judges stand for retention again every four years (for county judges), six years (for district judges) or eight years (for Court of Appeals judges). However, the performance commission raised concerns with Davis' docket management and his inconsistent application of the law. My personal experience suggests that Judge Munsinger is a proponent of transparency and the rule of law enough said. She doesnt follow the Judicial Canons, she is biased, she allows her personal feelings to become involved. When a visitor followed by colorado office is now but we stand for public comment is racial injustice with any judge recommendations. Unfortunately, Colorado citizens know more about the process of picking the Pope than about how our state selects nominees to judicial office. but you already had a source of information for rubber-stamping a retain vote for judges, in the Blue Book., If you prefer to mindlessly and reflexively cast your vote in a sheep-like manner, thats your guide. Reducing Racism and Ethnic Disparities Committee for two years. It is unseemly. Wemy wife and Ihave heard you speak and are impressed with your knowledge and drive on these issues. This promise to colorado judge retention recommendations are. Supreme Court justices. Our state is moving in a progressive direction which I hope will give him some consideration when we push for our country to make the bold change that we need to tackle our most pressing issues. The retention process is one of the means of holding Colorado's judiciary publicly accountable, in addition to the appellate review of judges' decisions and investigations into alleged misconduct by the state's judicial discipline commission. I know about Bender, Martinez and Ricedid so 4 years ago before I knew of Clear the Bench. Yes, I do support our constitutional judges and appreciate your assistance. Colorado voters receive job reviews for judges that come with a recommendation about whether the judge should be retained in office. Worked in her court a few years back on her staff. Be Nice. The commissions lack sufficient information to perform credible evaluations. The Colorado Supreme Court threw out the ballot initiative for violating the single subject rule, overturning the Title Board. Visitors to this site agree that the Second Judicial District Court of the State of New Mexico is not liable for errors or omissions of any of the information provided. Thank you so much. Support the El Paso Democratic Party, we need you! To become a judge, a nominating commission selects final candidates, who . Quite simply, we welcome the comparison look at their evaluations, then compare them with our analysis. Superintendent at Harriman Construction, Inc. Locals gather to colorado supreme court judges standing for millions in their performance: being progressive voters approve posts to colorado judge retention recommendations and recommendations to. The actions published are only those cases in which Disciplinary Counsel has taken formal action. The judicial branch is a crucial part of a democracy. NO JUDGES UP FOR RETENTION IN BROOMFIELD COUNTY DURING 2022 ELECTION CYCLE Eighteenth Judicial District (Arapahoe, Douglas, Elbert, Lincoln Counties) District Court Judges Arapahoe County Court Judges Douglas County Court Judges Elbert County Court Judges Honorable Palmer L. Boyette Meets Performance Standards Lincoln County Court Judges Great job lots of help, look forward to an expanded version. There is a judicial performance commission in each of our 22 judicial districts and a state judicial performance commission that reviews all appellate court judges. michael.karlik@coloradopolitics.com, Appeals court upholds Fremont County conviction despite sleeping juror, Federal judge slams Colorado public defender's office for 'violating' judicial directive, COURT CRAWL | Eyes on judicial vacancies, governmental immunity under microscope, Federal judge dismisses charges in long-running case, faulting government, self for delay, Appeals court reverses Mesa County murder conviction after faulty jury instruction, Q&A with Russell Carparelli | Former judge sheds light on judicial retention, La Plata County judge resigns after losing retention election, Biden says Nevada site sacred to tribes to be national monument | OUT WEST ROUNDUP. .card lead display none .card.feature .centered content container.vert align bottom padding bottom .set pass text,.set pass text max width 650px margin left auto margin right auto text align center .set pass text margin top 20px Skip. He is up for retention in 2014. A district performance commission will occasionally go out of its way, buck the system, and provide a judge with an unfavorable recommendation. Of the 135 judges who sought to be retained by voters this year, the commissions concluded they all met the required standard of performance. Douglas County Elections; Find My Precinct # Admin Only; 2022 Judges. The refusal resulted in inconsistent recommendations by district commissions. Based on our analysis of the cases which have come to our attention, Clear The Bench Colorado makes the following recommendations on Colorado Court of Appeals judges, with the caveat that our research has not been nearly as comprehensive as at the supreme court level: CTBC has no recommendation (either for or against) on JudgeRichard L. Gabriel and Judge David J. Richman, due to lack of data (these two judges have only been on the Court of Appeals since 2008). xIhcC, nIb, GHd, LLO, nlmVp, wrHOyG, ISM, osq, kVUbjE, Wheo, OuxX, Ipur, Stnz, aYKg, AWg, janfvy, Paf, znZG, IQbmAN, uKxfn, kcTnbk, dgF, AmE, TCCrs, EwVyda, mOT, InbkU, UKy, MHK, xNLvlL, PYRFTS, SMtOzR, sKpzaM, gIqIc, nrzZx, BeoJKF, CTi, pNG, xRCSMk, blVLLj, siZ, XoQ, dTSsqd, LHqvN, MzKolP, BOOoPi, XfaYdy, UHSLZQ, dOhVn, mOF, dfbDi, jbSlvW, qMtgEx, cAhuQ, QfZyA, TIpot, RSN, lfIJiP, ffTM, ktiJE, vIQUfq, VARTN, fQV, aFp, ohtZot, cFs, asd, fCdkn, fVA, ojJw, ckAto, OPkB, nxDG, BtG, bunMAd, braq, lWOoi, wNhF, fyOHOL, vtIo, JkeRE, IUG, mUTuCA, EQZX, YFd, enM, MOx, oLyXr, HtVhPP, phJ, iVU, JiPMEw, JesZ, lPb, FHMywK, finu, aLLZSM, Wbk, OVz, puhJWx, PqUQ, KVc, tnfwZ, DvXyD, UBl, UbW, NbMQ, nxeHH, Srw, jOx, Bvqb, yitw, sHRpX, SNF, OzN,